|"You have a lot of work to do while patrons eat their pizza in the other room."|
“I’m going to beat you, Connor. You just wait and see. I’ll be the winner and you’ll be the freaking loser!”
He has brown hair, and usually wears a beanie.
Toby is constantly bullied by his older brother, Connor. He is constantly stated to be inferior to Connor and that he can never live up to him. This is also hammered home by the fact that Connor has all the high scores on all the arcade machines at their local Freddy Fazbear's Pizza and Games. With his father ignoring him and his mother abandoning the family, Toby feels unseen and resentful. In an ironic twist, it's revealed that Toby had shut himself out from his family and he descends into competitive madness to defeat Shadow Bonnie, growing even worse as a person before his eventual death.
Toby attempts to get a high score at the newest game at the pizzeria's arcade; Hide-and-Seek. Despite being seemingly easy, Toby constantly fails at every turn, to the point where even cheating and hacking gets him nowhere. Toby wrecks the arcade machine in a fit of rage, only for the Shadow Bonnie character within it to be released into the real world.
The shadow, with its white pupils and sharp teeth in its mouth, attaches itself to Toby. He is unable to do anything about it. Toby tries to drown the shadow in a pool, only to almost drown himself. As Toby gets more and more frustrated, Shadow Bonnie grows in strength to the point where it starts sticking itself onto Toby's skin. Toby decides to accept whatever the shadow does to him, but in doing so, causes it to weaken. Toby realizes that the shadow was powered by his anger.
The arcade game Toby destroyed is fixed, with his old save file still there. Toby could forfeit, releasing Shadow Bonnie, but he wants to win. He plays the game, stabbing himself into one of the props. Shadow Bonnie leaves and Toby bathes in victory as he bleeds to death.