|"You have a lot of work to do while patrons eat their pizza in the other room."|
“Is it time to go back already?”
She is one year older than her sister Samantha.
Susie has light-brown hair that flows on her face and brown eyes that were usually wide open. As a result, she often looked mischievous and energetic. She was usually called cute because of her small nose and mouth.
She was wearing a magenta-and-pink striped sweater and jeans embedded with rhinestones when she was murdered. She wears the same clothes when she meets with Samantha.
Susie enjoys doing "frivolous" activities, such as naming trees or playing with her dolls. She also seems to understand other people's emotions in a way most people are not able to; she recognizes emotions as colors and smells. She is very creative.
About a year ago, Susie was murdered at Freddy Fazbear's Pizza. Her spirit still lingers in the house as she observes her family mourning her loss. She doesn't quite understand what happened; she just knows that everyone is sad from some event. She tries to communicate with them, but to no avail.
Every night, Chica wanders her house searching for her. Every night, Susie takes Chica's hand and leaves the house.
When Samantha is at therapy, Susie overhears her talking about Gretchen, a special doll of hers. She realizes that she doesn't remember where she hid the doll. To communicate with Samantha, she makes drawings for her to see. She tells her to find Gretchen and that she only has two days left.
On her final day, Susie begins to walk away with Chica, until she sees Samantha carrying Gretchen. She convinces Chica to let her meet Samantha for the last time. They hug, and Samantha gives the doll to Susie. Susie walks away with Chica and disappears.
- This Susie's appearance is different from her game and novel trilogy counterparts. In this story Susie has long brown hair and brown eyes, while in the games and original books she has curly long blond hair and blue eyes.
- Fazbear Frights #4: Step Closer | Coming Home | "Susie’s light-brown hair flowed around her face; Samantha’s was caught tight in a ponytail."
- Fazbear Frights #4: Step Closer | Coming Home | "Susie’s brown eyes were usually wide open, while Samantha’s were often squinting, so Susie looked eager and Samantha looked cautious."
- Fazbear Frights #4: Step Closer | Coming Home | "She looked the same way she’d looked the day she was abducted. She even wore the same clothes—her magenta-and-pink striped sweater and the jeans Jeanie had studded with rhinestones."