- Not to be confused with Sarah Avery, a character from the Dance with Me story of Fazbear Frights 4: Step Closer.
“I want... to be beautiful.”
Sarah has frizzy brown hair, blue eyes, and Caucasian skin. She describes herself as being flat and fat. She likes to wear makeup to make herself more beautiful.
After the makeover from Eleanor, Sarah becomes a lot more attractive. Her arms and legs become slimmer, and she becomes taller. Her hair and nose become straighter, and her eyes become wider and deeper. She is told by Eleanor to always wear a special necklace, and she wears fancier clothes to accentuate her new body.
When the necklace falls off, Sarah's body slowly reveals itself to be a scrap metal endoskeleton. As parts of her new "body" falls off, she eventually turns into a pile of scrap metal.
Sarah is very vain and has low self esteem. She is pretty clumsy and not aware of her surroundings, and is obsessed with modelling and her appearance. When becoming beautiful, she soon becomes very self absorbent and gets angry at Abby for not accepting her obsession with being beautiful.
Sarah is an unpopular girl with low self esteem as she doesn't like her appearance. She is obsessed with the idea of being "beautiful" and wants to be popular.
One day, on her way home from school, she comes across mechanical doll in a scrapyard. Finding her absolutely gorgeous, Sarah takes her home and cleans her up. When the doll awakens, she introduces herself as Eleanor and shows gratitude for what Sarah had done and says that to show her appreciation, she would grant any of Sarah's wishes. Sarah wishes to be beautiful, and Eleanor agrees to grant this wish. She gives a heart-shaped necklace to Sarah, telling her to never take it off under any circumstance, to which Sarah agrees.
From then on, every night, Eleanor would sing Sarah to sleep before changing an aspect of her body to make her appear more beautiful. At first, her arms are changed to be more slender, longer, and with polished nails. The next day, her legs follow a similar change as her arms. After this, she starts to get a little more attention at school. Finally, her torso is changed to have a flatter stomach and larger breasts, giving her a more womanly figure.
With each change, Sarah became more entranced with her new appearance. This prompted her to start pushing away her best friend Abby as she worked her way in with the popular girls, whom she referred to as the Beautifuls. She also started to catch the eye of her long-time crush, Mason Blair, even starting a relationship and going on dates with him. However, in all of this, Sarah started to lie about her home life, pretending she was wealthier than she was and that her father was still around all in the name of trying to fit in.
One day at school, Sarah's new shoes cause her to slip and fall hard, causing her necklace to come off. Slowly, her body begins turning into scrap metal, to the shock of everyone in the cafeteria. As her body continues to turn into metal, Sarah runs home. In her house, she finds garbage bags full of body parts and organs. She realizes that Eleanor has been replacing her body parts with metal every night.
Still steadily turning into a pile of scrap metal, she sees Eleanor, now sporting a heart-shaped necklace of her own. Pressing a button on the necklace, Eleanor takes the appearance of Sarah, particularly the one she had before Eleanor began to make her "beautiful". She then walks away, leaving Sarah to die alone.
Sarah's father left Sarah when she was three, leaving her mother to care for her. Sarah's mother doesn't care about beauty, but she helps her daughter buy new clothes and drives her to the mall.
Sarah's most loyal friend. She is not interested in beauty, and disapproves of the Beautifuls. Sarah realizes at the end of the story that she was her only real friend.
The four most prettiest girls of Sarah's school: Lydia, Jillian, Tabitha, and Emma. Sarah wishes to be a part of the group, and is accepted when she is made more beautiful by Eleanor.
Sarah's crush and eventual boyfriend. Though she initially embarrasses herself by spilling salad on him, her transformation by Eleanor gives her the courage and beauty to date him.