Old Man Consequences appears to be a red colored 8-bit sprite figure in a sitting position. He has what appears to be large teeth and a head shaped somewhat like that of a crocodile or alligator. He holds a fishing rod much larger than himself with no hook. He seems to have gotten his name because he had to take the consequences of something, or because he explains the consequences of entering the fourth sub-tunnel.
Nothing much is known about Old Man Consequences, however due to his role in Ultimate Custom Night, he seems to be very wise and intelligent. He is also very helpful when it comes to helping others out with grudges and situations.