Hear me out. FNAF 2 took place before FNAF 1, the toy animatronics were possessed from the start. Here are my reasons.
the toys are active from night one while the withered are not.
While the OG 5 were lured into the back room and stuffed into the suits, the FNAF 2 victims are seen all around the pizzeria out in the open on the save them minigame instead of all in parts and service
They are all dead at the same time. In FNAF one, one of the posters say 2 kids go missing on the same day, presuming that all the children were taken at separate times.
The withered animatronics are active at separate nights like spirits are being added to the suits.
I think the toy animatronics were possessed before the OG models.
Also this was literally a shower thought
@BMega007 @Badtimepacifist @EndrManiacWiki @MrPotatoDude01 @MaybeNotMewo @Purket