I've played DSAF, ONAF, and FNW39, and I think DSAF is my favorite.

DSaF overrated af tbh, humor and gameplay have aged extremely poorly plus story sucks

Very nice opinion, unfortunately Popgoes the Weasel has stuffed 300 pounds of asbestos into your attic.

Say what you will, but that joke never aged.

I mean same but it doesn't really impact my opinion of the game

DSaF just isn't nearly as good as DD's other projects (namely Dialtown) and the story is too edgy for its own good

As a DSAF fan, I don't really like DSAF fans.

And honestly, say what you will about the story, but I liked Dr. Henry Miller as a villain. A crazed mechanical engineer bent on abolishing death, no matter who he had to kill to achieve it, that's the William Afton we should've got.

Tyke And Sons is one of the best FNAF fangames period, not even just in the more silly category

I think it’d have more votes in this poll if it was just a little more well known

Five Nights With 39 is also really fun, and it’s fun to revisit nowadays since it’s such a time capsule of that mid 2010s style of humor

Tyke and sons isn't not well known tho, it's made by Mixlas (prominent dev) and has like 8k followers on GJ

Calling it one of the best is a stretch though, it isn't even his best work

Never seen any other dsaf fan other than aubergine (haven't seen any fangame fan ever lol)

Honestly I like all of this games! (Beaides FNIA)

But I've always choosen Comedy over Horror so

Fnia would have been better if the game over screen shows night guard stuffed in anime boy suit and had disturbing lore like midori and saki sanobashi :(